Everything bagels on a cooling rack

12 Everything But The Bagel Seasoning Products You Need To Try

There’s no doubt that our world was forever changed in 2017 with the release of Trader Joe’s Everything But The Bagel Seasoning. The modestly priced seasoning instantly became a cult favorite, prompting a slew of copycats and everything bagel flavored, well, everything, in the years since. And when we say everything, we mean everything.

Trader Joe’s gave their customers exactly what they wanted with an entire line of Everything But The Bagel seasoned items ranging from chips and dips to smoked salmon. Then Aldi’s, followed suit with products like Everything Franks In A Blanket. Then came everything flavored nuts, chips, and pre-made dips. And 2021 is the year that brought us Jeni’s Everything Bagel ice cream (cue ‘squee’).

If you can’t get enough of all things everything bagel, we’ve gone ahead and rounded up 12 everything bagel flavored products to satisfy all of your cravings.

Trader Joe’s Everything But The Bagel Seasoning

The OG Everything But The Bagel launch, this seasoning is inspired by all the goodies normally found atop an everything bagel – white and black sesame seeds, poppy seeds, dried garlic & onion, and sea salt flakes, according to the Trader Joe’s website. Shop it here.

Trader Joe’s Everything But The Bagel Smoked Salmon

Love lox? Trader Joe’s takes its seasoning to another level with its smoked salmon. The combo of savory and smoky, soft & crunchy makes it an elevated option for hors d’oeuvres, eggs benedict, salads, or your standard brunch bagel spread, the store says. Shop it here.

Jeni’s Ice Cream Everything Bagel

How can you go wrong with cream cheese ice cream? You can’t. But you can make it better with some everything bagel seasoning. Now, you can get your bagel fix after dinner, too. Although currently sold-out, you can sign up for a notification when the super original flavor is back in stock. Shop it here.

Bloody Revolution Everything Bagel Bloody Mary Mix

Looking to up the ante on your breakfast cocktail? Now you can with everything bagel flavored Bloody Mary mix. Bloody Revolution loads up on white and black sesame seeds, minced garlic, minced onion, poppy seed, pretzel salt and our own blend of other complimentary spices. Shop it here.

Eliot’s Everything Bagel Nut Butter

Nut butter and everything bagel seasoning? Yes, please! Eliot’s nut butter is small-batch produced and vegan. The nut butter blend of sunflower seeds, cashews, hazelnuts and almonds holds up well to the addition to everything bagel seasoning. Shop it here.

SkinnyPop Everything Bagel Popcorn Mini Cakes

Popcorn and everything bagel seasoning is like a match made in heaven. These popcorn mini cakes are the perfect bite-sized snack to help get your everything fix on the go. Shop it here.

Sheffa Savory Everything Snack Bars

Another great on-the-go everything bagel style snack are Sheffa’s snack bars. These bars are baked and seasoned with everything bagel seasoning. But, not only that, these goodies are also gluten-free, vegan and are made with a whole grain blend. Shop it here.

Nuts.com Everything Sesame Sticks

Topped with everything bagel seasoning, these savory bites are the perfect accompaniment for cheese. They also make a great nosh while enjoying an at-home cocktail hour. Shop it here.

Field Trip Everything Bagel Beef Jerky

It may sound odd, but it’s a unique combination that is like a savory overload. Made from 100% grass-fed beef, these jerky snacks are gluten free and have no preservatives. The hint of salt, onion and garlic from the everything seasoning perfectly complements the flavor of the beef. Shop it here.

Vermont Creamery Everything Goat Cheese

Just like an everything bagel with cream cheese, Vermont Creamery’s everything goat cheese is hand rolled in seasoning so not a spot is missed. Perfect for a charcuterie board or cheese platter or on your morning toast. Shop it here.

Aldi’s Everything Franks In A Blanket

Your favorite game day snack just got better. Aldi has added everything bagel seasoning to its crusty mini-franks roll for a taste all their own. This souped-up appetizer is so good that one box just won’t cut it. Shop it here.

Rhythm Superfoods Everything Bagel Broccoli Bites

These babies make eating your greens even more delicious. These crispy, chip-like broccoli bites are covered in everything bagel seasoning. They’re also great for on-the-go, keeping you from getting that hangry feeling no matter where the day takes you. Shop it here.

Leave a Comment